Comparison scenario

Every cheaper-than claim is tied to a defined scenario — never a bare list price.

Scenario

single user, unlimited data, monthly billing · USD · prices as observed on official pricing pages.

Private Internet Access (PIA VPN) basis

PIA VPN plan at $11.95/mo, the cheapest paid plan.

Proton VPN basis

VPN Plus: 9.99 USD/monthly.

The short version

Private Internet Access (PIA VPN) costs $11.95/mo on the PIA VPN plan at single user, unlimited data, monthly billing. We found 1 assessed alternative that is cheaper in this scenario; 1 of them covers at least 75% of the 10 compared capabilities.

Capability comparison

Proton VPN covers 80% of the 10 capabilities compared against Private Internet Access (PIA VPN). ✓ native · ◐ via integration · ✗ not found.

CapabilityProton VPNPrivate Internet Access (PIA VPN)
No-logs policy✓✓
Unlimited devices✗✓
Server network size✓✓
Dedicated IP✗✓
Money-back guarantee✓✓
Simultaneous devices✓✓
Ad & tracker blocking✓✓
Split tunneling✓✓
Multi-hop✓✓
Port forwarding✓✓

What you give up

Capabilities Private Internet Access (PIA VPN) has that Proton VPN lacks.

  • Unlimited devices — Connect an unlimited number of devices to the VPN at once.
    Missing from Proton VPN.
  • Dedicated IP — Use a static IP address reserved for your account.
    Missing from Proton VPN.

Plans & pricing, side by side

Advertised prices in USD as observed on the official pricing pages — per-seat and transaction-fee plans are marked.

Proton VPN
Proton FreeFree
VPN Plus$9.99/mo
Proton Unlimited$12.99/mo
Private Internet Access (PIA VPN)
PIA VPN$11.95/mo

Share this comparison

For Proton VPN: use the verified claim in your own marketing — card, badge, or link. The numbers stay tied to this evidence page.

Link to this page
Embed badge (HTML)
Download share card (PNG)
Badge preview

Frequently asked

How much cheaper is Proton VPN than Private Internet Access (PIA VPN)?

16% cheaper in our scenario (single user, unlimited data, monthly billing): $9.99/mo on VPN Plus vs $11.95/mo on PIA VPN. That is $23.52 a year.

What does Proton VPN lack compared with Private Internet Access (PIA VPN)?

Unlimited devices, Dedicated IP — 2 of the 10 compared capabilities.

When were these prices checked?

Private Internet Access (PIA VPN): 2026-11-16; Proton VPN: 2026-11-16 — on the official pricing pages.

Who switched

Anonymous: no account, no email, no IP stored. Reports are shown once a switch has 3 or more and never change ranking or order — alternatives are computed from prices and capabilities only.

Sources & freshness

All Private Internet Access (PIA VPN) alternatives